Cape Town - If African victims could get justice in their
own countries, there would be no need for the International Criminal Court
(ICC) to step in, former UN secretary general Kofi Annan said on Monday.
Speaking at the third annual Desmond Tutu International
Peace Lecture, Annan came to the defence of the ICC - which had come under
increasing criticism from African countries for "unfairly targeting
"On a continent that has experienced deadly conflict,
gross violations of human rights, even genocide, I am surprised to hear critics
ask whether the pursuit of justice might obstruct the search for peace,"
Annan told a packed University of the Western Cape main hall.
Annan said justice and peace were interlinked, and one could
not be achieved without the other.
"We must be ambitious enough to pursue both, and wise
enough to recognise, respect and protect the independence of justice," he
"And we must always have the courage to ask ourselves 'who
speaks for the victims'?"
Annan bemoaned the fact that "the victims of the worst
crimes" in Africa had been failed due to inaction against the
In most cases, it was Africans that sought justice, when
courts in their own countries had failed them.
Court of last resort
"In four of the cases on Africa before the court,
African leaders themselves made the referral to the ICC. In two others - Darfur
and more recently Libya - it was the United Nations Security Council, and not
the Court, which initiated proceedings," he said.
Speaking to media shortly after his address, Annan
reiterated the ICC was set up as a court of last resort.
"If African victims can get justice at home and we have
credible courts and they do take action there'll be no need for [the]
ICC," Annan said.
Earlier in his speech, Annan spoke out against the
"winner takes all" approach to politics on the continent.
"We have seen how this has led to abuses of power by
the winner and encouraged losers to reject democracy as a peaceful means for
change," he said.
"Too often, the individual interests of leaders have
been misconstrued as interests of their country."
Annan also paid tribute to Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Tutu
- who celebrated his 82nd birthday.
"Desmond has always found the courage, no matter how
uncomfortable or dangerous, to speak truth to power."
Introducing Annan to the crowd earlier on, Tutu said he was
"deeply blessed" that Annan had chosen to speak at the lecture,
describing the former UN chief as "humble".
"Unfortunately, you won't see he's blushing," Tutu
told guests who roared with laughter.
In his brief introduction, Tutu said he "felt sorry for
The Arch - as he's affectionately known around the world -
made brief reference to the strife in Syria and the Democratic Republic of
"Can you imagine what it must be like for God...
looking down saying those are my children in Syria, those using chemical
weapons are my children, those dying are my children," Tutu said.