Create Profile

Creating your profile will enable you to submit photos and stories to get published on News24.

Please provide a username for your profile page:

This username must be unique, cannot be edited and will be used in the URL to your profile page across the entire 24.com network.

Facebook Sign-In

Hi News addict,

Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.

Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.


Questions over ethics of Ebola placebo

14 October 2014, 07:55

Abuja - A group of influential health experts has argued the standard practice of using placebos in drug trials would be unethical in the case of experimental medicines for Ebola, given that the world is in the middle of a deadly epidemic.

Faced with a disease where the death rate is between 40 and 90 percent, randomised controlled trials (RCTs) - where patients are assigned to get either the drug or a dummy pill - would be unfair and ethically unacceptable, according to the disease specialists from Europe, Africa and the United States.

"We accept that RCTs can generate strong evidence in ordinary circumstances; not, however, in the midst of the worst Ebola epidemic in history," experts including David Heymann, head of the Chatham House Centre on Global Health Security, wrote in a letter to the Lancet medical journal.

Some trials of potential Ebola treatments or vaccines in West Africa have just begun, or are due to start in the coming months, and the World Health Organization (WHO) has said it hopes some medicines may start to be deployed in the West Africa outbreak early next year.

A different group of disease experts last month argued in a letter to the Journal of the American Medical Association that experimental Ebola drugs were best tested in normal RCTs.

Similar debate with cancer research

A similar debate is going on in the field of cancer drugs, where researchers increasingly question whether randomisation - where some patients are given a treatment and others get a "control" substance for comparison - makes sense in patients with an incurable disease.

In cancer, new trial designs are being pioneered that allow faster testing on experimental medicines in smaller, more targeted groups, potentially shaving major costs and significant time off the usual drug development process.

The Ebola expert group writing in the Lancet - which also included Peter Piot, a professor and director at the London School of Tropical Medicine who was one of the discoverers of Ebola - stressed that "the urgent need is to establish whether new drugs offer survival benefits" and therefore which, if any, should be recommended by the WHO to save lives.

"We have innovative but proven trial designs for doing exactly that," they wrote. "We should be using them, rather than doggedly insisting on gold standards that were developed for different settings and purposes."

The Ebola epidemic has infected almost 8,400 people so far and killed more than 4,000 of them, mainly in Guinea, Sierra Leone and Liberia.

Test two different drugs at once

One potential drug trial design that would avoid using placebos would be to test two experimental drugs at the same time by giving one to one group and another to a separate group.

"In cancers with a poor prognosis for which there are no good treatments, evidence from studies without a control group can be accepted as sufficient for deployment, and even for licensing by regulators, with fuller analysis following later," the experts wrote.

"There is no need for rules to be bent or corners to be cut: the necessary procedures already exist, and are used."

The WHO has approved the use of experimental drugs for Ebola in the hope they might help some people infected in the outbreak which has been raging since March.

Several patients have already been given experimental drugs including ZMapp, made by Mapp Biopharmaceutical in the United States, TKM-Ebola made by Canada's Tekmira, and brincidofovir, made by the U.S. company Chimerix.

But since only a tiny number of patients have been treated and some of those treated died and some survived, doctors don't know for sure if they work.

In the letter to JAMA, disease experts argued that conducting RCTs was the only way to "maximise lives saved in the present epidemic and ensure knowledge gains for the next".

Heymann, Piot and 15 other signatories to the Lancet letter said: "We disagree".

"No one insisted that western medical workers offered ZMapp and other investigational products were randomised to receive the drug or conventional care plus a placebo," they wrote.

"None of us would consent to be randomised in such circumstances."

- Health24

For the latest on national news, politics, sport, entertainment and more follow us on Twitter and like our Facebook page.


Read News24’s Comments Policy

Comment on this story
Comments have been closed for this article.

Read more from our Users

Nigeria @ 56: Words to my green f...

A leader’s job is not to dictate, but rather to be respected, admired and be a trustee, of the land we love, with so much potential, a land which should be freer than free. Its still a long way to fufilling our destiny! Read more...

Submitted by
Isaac Asabor263
Recession: An opportunity for Nig...

The recession should be seen as an opportunity for the country’s promotion as long as we all collectively conduct ourselves in a patriotic manner, writes Isaac Asabor.  Read more...

Submitted by
Black and White

We want to imitate the whites in everything because we are ignorant of our inherent originality and content. We spend all our Naira to acquire his inventions because we so oblivious of our natural endowments that we allow him have it for free. Read more...

Submitted by
Nate Nat
Adamawa State University Mubi: A ...

ADSU integrity forum has accused the Sunday Joshua Wugira, a lawyer, of adopting unorthodox tactics by abusing his privilege by attacking the integrity of ADSU Vice Chancellor Dr. Moses Zira Zaruwa, writes a News24 reader. Read more...

Submitted by
Abdulsalam Jubril
My Country Nigeria (Part One)

Poetry by Abdulsalam Jubril.

Submitted by
Abdulsalam Jubril
Recession, dearth in leadership a...

Every leader has the opportunity to become great and making himself immortal in the lives and hearts of people for generations to come. Will Mr. President seize this opportunity?, questions Abdulsalam Jubril. Read more...